Thanksgiving Dinner Wine Pairings with Tips from Robert Parker

I do not know about you, but Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. It’s been that way for years. For our family, it is the one time each year when all the different family members come to the house and spend time together. When did spending time become a euphemism for eating and drinking? At our house, the vast array of comfort foods with their diverse range of flavors makes it fun and occasionally difficult to fit a bite of everything on just one plate. But what wines should you serve that will please all your guests while making good Thanksgiving dinner wine and food pairings? Do you offer one wine, in a one size fits all? Should you open a wide variety of wines? Or, is it better to go all out and do both with the desire to provide the best Thanksgiving dinner wine pairings?

We asked the world’s most popular wine wine, Robert Parker what he prefers when it comes to does at his home for Thanksgiving dinner wine pairings.

Robert Parker “We open several different wines. From the Southern Rhone Valley, Chateauneuf du Pape, Vacqueyras and Gigondas.”

As Thanksgiving is a traditional American holiday, do you serve any California wines?

Robert Parker “Zinfandel.”

At our home, most of the wines are red as well. But some family members prefer white wines. Do you and Pat open any white wines at the Parker house?

Robert Parker “For the Thanksgiving white wines, we open Champagne and wines from Alsace.”

Pairing wine with many Thanksgiving dishes can pose problems. Some people worry endlessly about what wine to pair with each course. They fret over which flavors perfectly meld with the wines to create the right match.  And don’t get me started on the spice or aromatic qualities in a wine measured against what they might find on their plate. Personally, I like the concept of matching similar textures better.

We asked Robert Parker what he looks for when matching Thanksgiving turkey dinners with wine at his home.

Robert Parker “First, it’s important to match the intensity of the cuisine to the intensity of the wine. You want light wines with light dishes. Rich wines with rich dishes.”

There are people that in my view, give far too much thought as to marrying red wines with only red dishes and white wines with light dishes. For Thanksgiving, I find that rule does not apply with some many divergent flavors on the table. Do you give thought to the color of the wine for specific courses on Thanksgiving?

Robert Parker “Keeping with the old standard rule, rich equals rich color is unimportant. Secondly, is the texture. For Thanksgiving wine and food pairings, the textures of the wine and food should align. They should not be opposites.”

Because I’m curious, how many different wines will you open for a typical Thanksgiving dinner at the Parker house?

Robert Parker “Normally we open about 12-18 red Southern Rhone wines. We also keep Champagnes on hand for white wine drinkers.”

By the way, if you’re in London in February, Robert Parker is hosting two don’t miss events. There is a Master Class, February 26 followed by a dinner any true hedonist should not miss at my favorite restaurant in London, The Ledbury!

I agree with the advice from Robert Parker when it comes to Thanksgiving wine pairing and food matching’s. Don’t get me wrong.  There are food and wine pairings that naturally work better than others.  But it never does any good to serve wines you or your guests do not like, simply because someone says it makes for a better pairing.

I prefer drinking wines I like.  It does not matter if the greatest wine and food pairing on Earth matches Gewurztraminer with smoked turkey.  I do not like lychee nut flavors. So while Gewurztraminer is said to pair well with smoked and spicy flavors, it does not work for my taste, because lychee flavors are such a turn off for me.

The following simple rules should help you find the best wine for your Thanksgiving wine pairings.

Rule #1 When thinking about which wines to open for the best Thanksgiving wine pairings, serve wine people are going to like.  It might sound like a simple explanation, but simple is often the best solution. Especially when it comes to Thanksgiving wine pairings. If you want to enhance rule #1, with a few exceptions, often the color of the wine is going to make a good match with food of a similar color. Think of lamb with red Bordeaux wine, or turkey with a white wine for an easy example. Pairing wine with food is supposed to be fun, not rocket science.

Turkey can be on the dry side, so it requires wines with flavor to wake it up.  It’s not the turkey that is a difficult wine and food pairing problem, it’s the diversity of flavors found in most of the sweet, side dishes served along with the turkey.  To many  people cooking a turkey is intimidating, due to the fact that a turkey is a large bird.  The truth is, turkeys are easy to cook.

The secret to brine the turkey first. Do not buy too large a bird. Most importantly, don’t overcook it! Remove the turkey from the oven at 155 degrees, let it rest while it continues to cook.  As an average guide, you need approximately 20 minutes per pound at about 325 degrees for the turkey to cook through.  Remember all the holidays you were forced to a turkey that was so dry, you could barely chew it, let alone wash it down or swallow it!  Don’t let that happen to you. Brine it if you can.  

A brine is a simple method of adding flavor and moisture, all it takes is water, salt, pepper, honey, spice and herbs of your choice. Add fresh lemon, lime, orange or tangerine in your brine if that interests you as well.  Use an injector if you can’t brine and don’t cook the bird until it’s nuked.  Nothing is more harmful to a turkey than overcooking it! That’s all there is to it.

If you are too busy drinking the wine we recommend and you accidentally overcook your bird, don’t be shy with the gravy. Use it and pour it over the bird.  If you’re out of gravy, drizzle melted butter.   If you’re out of gravy and butter, pour more wine for everyone!

With that in mind, what can a host do to serve wines people are going to like, that will not break the bank, knowing Thanksgiving dishes are prone to being on the sweet side?  Start with Rule #1 and do not worry about it.

Traditional Thanksgiving side dishes are the best part of the meal.  I love stuffing. Few foods offer as much comfort feeling as traditional cornbread and sausage stuffing!  It’s my favorite part of the meal.  Stuffing is semi neutral in flavor, depending on the ingredients. Creamy flavors are easy to math as well. It’s the cranberry, yam and marshmallow, string bean casserole and various, assorted, sweet dishes that are hard to pair with wine.   That is why Rule #1 is so important.

Consumers are fortunate this year, because the stores are filled with great wines that offer value and flavor in red, white and sparkling wines at all price ranges.

Thanksgiving and all the year-end holidays are festive occasions.  One way to go is to start the dinner off with Champagne, or sparkling wines.  If you have the money, Dom Perignon is sublime and it’s drinking perfectly today.  However, there are much less costly alternatives. Look for NV Schramsberg NV Mirabelle Brut from California or one of the many grower Champagnes in the stores today. If you’re like me and prefer Champagne, look for Laurent Perrier NV, Tarlant NV Brut, Elgy Ouriet Tradition Grand Cru, Chartogne Taillet, Moet and Chandon Brut Imperial or Charles Heidseck Brut Reserve are all reasonable ways to start the festivities.  If sparkling wines are not your thing, the opportunities for purchasing quality, reasonably priced red and white wines are endless this year.

It’s no secret that the Rhone Valley is stacked with food friendly wines of pleasure today. Look for Cotes du Rhone from Janasse, Clos du Caillou, Grand Venur, Domaine de Coteaux, Domaine les Grand Bois, Perrin et Fils, Beaucastel Coudoulet, Delas, Jaboulet and Chapoutier. Most of those wines and dozens of other great values sell for $20 or less!  For a bit more money, there are so many great Chateauneuf du Pape wines available now that are out of this world! While some people make fun of the easy drinking, Beaujolais, wines, there are good, food friendly, Beaujolais Nouveau wines that are worth considering.

If the Rhone Valley is not your thing, numerous, forward styled 2009 Bordeaux wine are in the stores. They might not pair quite as well as the wines from the Rhone, but they are already delicious. Look for 2009 and 2010 Bordeaux Superieur and 2009 and 2010 Cotes de Bordeaux wines.  You can even find some tremendous deals from the satellite regions of St. Emilion as well as St. Emilion, for example La Fleur Morange Mathilde is great. Try and find wines from La Vieille Cure, Reignac, Croix Mouton, Le Conseiller, Vrai Canon Bouche and La Prade.  Red Bordeaux is your only choice from the appellation.  Sauternes from vintages that are not overly sweet, like 2008 are good ideas.  One of the top sweet white Bordeaux wines today is being produced by Chateau Coutet. Depending on how you make your turkey, you can easily make a great Thanksgiving dinner wine pairing with these delicious sweet wines.

If you’re seeking wines from the Golden State, the best values in California wine are usually found in Syrah, Zinfandel, Pinot Noir and Chardonnay.

While some people find too much sweetness in California wines for Thanksgiving, if those wines offer the flavor profile you’re seeking, those are the wines to open. While we have been focusing on a few ideas for red wines, numerous choices for white wines are in the marketplace today.  The wines range in style from fat and buttery, to crisp, stony and fresh with flavors that vary from citrus to tropical.  If you’re worried about what style of white wine you need to buy, remember rule #1! Back to white wines for a moment, Chardonnay is not the only white wine to consider for Thanksgiving, look for crisp, refreshing Riesling, Sauvignon Blanc, Semillon, Pinot Grigio, Pinot Gris and yes, even Gewurztraminer, just don’t serve it to the lychee nut averse.

If you have other ideas for wines on Thanksgiving, please post and share.  There are so many great pairings, we have not even scratched the surface.

Related posts:

2000 Bordeaux Wine Tasted With Robert Parker, Tasting Notes, Ratings Robert Parker Kicks Off First World Tour Grand Wine Events February 26 Matching Bordeaux Wine and Food Pairings with 10 Easy Tips Friends From Bordeaux Come to Dinner